It's the mark of a great band if even their fans can't agree on which of their albums is better...
I might be in a minority here, but I absolutely love the new Lacuna Coil album. It seems to strike a healthy balance between
Comalies and the more typically radio-friendly American sound of
Karmacode, and everyone's playing well. Cristina's voice continues to get stronger with every album, too: there's some fantastic stuff on the new record. My only real complaint is that they seem dangerously close to settling into a rut - it'd be nice to see them stretch out a little bit with longer tracks and a touch more variety (probably why
Unleashed Memories is still my favourite Coil album). Still, there's always the future. Based on my half-a-dozen listens so far, I'm quite impressed.
Within Temptation - I'm one of the awkward ones that likes the early and recent stuff, but not the stuff in the middle so much. I tend to agree with Tom that
Mother Earth isn't all that great - and I
love Kate Bush! It's not so much the vocal style for me, more the way the songs are all arranged quite similarly, and the production is really thick and dense to the degree that it all kind of mushes together. I think there are probably some great songs in there struggling to get out, but they're swamped by what has been done to them in the studio.
Favourite WT album is probably
The Heart Of Everything - which would probably get me burnt at the stake over on the WT forum!
